Private market valuations have always required judgment. But when market conditions can change quickly, fund managers face a bigger question: is the process behind those valuations keeping pace?

Our recent webinar, The Private Markets Confidence Reset: Is Your NAV Defensible?, explored where valuation processes come under scrutiny and what fund managers can do to strengthen confidence in their valuations through better governance, documentation and ongoing portfolio monitoring.

Here are five key takeaways from their discussion.

1. A defensible NAV is about more than the model

A sound valuation methodology is important, but it is only part of the equation.

Auditors and regulators also want to understand the process behind the valuation: Who prepares the mark? Who reviews or challenges it? How are significant judgments made? And can the firm show that it actually follows its valuation policy?

Strong valuation governance requires more than a policy on paper. There needs to be evidence that the review and challenge process is actually being followed.

2. Market conditions can move faster than private marks

Public markets can react quickly to changing conditions, while private valuations are typically updated quarterly.

The recent repricing of publicly traded software companies amid AI disruption is one example. As public-market multiples adjusted, private valuations did not necessarily move at the same pace, raising questions about whether the assumptions behind those marks were still appropriate.

That does not mean private marks should mirror public markets. It does mean managers should regularly review whether changing market signals could affect the assumptions underlying their valuations.

The key question: What has changed since the last valuation, and does it matter?

3. Document the judgement behind the valuation

A strong valuation process is only as defensible as the evidence supporting it.

That includes committee discussions, changes in assumptions and the reasons for selecting or removing comparable companies. For example, if the valuation committee already meets quarterly, keeping meeting minutes or sending a brief summary email can provide auditors with evidence that the review actually took place. The goal is not documentation for documentation’s sake. It is creating a clear record of how and why a valuation decision was made.

4. Monitoring leading indicators, not just financial results

Some indicators of portfolio-company performance may show up before they are reflected in traditional financial reporting.

Depending on the company and industry, customer retention, churn and customer acquisition costs can tell managers something that quarterly financial results have not yet captured.

Tracking the right indicators between valuation dates can help managers identify risks sooner and determine when a valuation deserves a closer look.

5. Valuation is becoming a broader risk-management conversation

Perhaps the biggest takeaway is that valuation should not be viewed solely as a financial reporting or compliance exercise.

When investors question private marks, the effects can reach beyond the audit. When investors question private marks, the effects can reach beyond the audit. Questions about valuation can affect redemption requests, create liquidity pressures and make it harder to raise the next fund.

For fund managers, that creates an opportunity to think more broadly about the role valuation plays across the organization and whether the existing process provides the transparency and rigor stakeholders increasingly expect.

Is your NAV defensible?

These five takeaways point to a few questions fund managers should be asking about their own valuation processes:

The answers can identify where a valuation process is strong and where there may be room to improve.

Watch The Private Markets Confidence Reset: Is Your NAV Defensible? for the full conversation and additional insights on valuation governance, market calibration and portfolio monitoring.
Withum plus signs.

Have Questions or Need Guidance?

If you’re a fund manager looking to strengthen your valuation process, review valuation assumptions or address questions about your portfolio valuations, Withum’s Financial Reporting Valuation Team can help.

Contact Us

Related Insights

Read more
Financial market chart with candlestick data, price trends, analytics and investment growth concept.
Energy Price Volatility, Margin Erosion and Hedging – Implementation Pitfalls for Commodity Hedgers

In the first quarter of 2026, Brent crude nearly doubled, from $61 to $118 a barrel, its largest inflation-adjusted quarterly increase in data going back to 1988. For an unhedged company, a move like that goes straight to the margin. Take a manufacturer with $40 million in revenue, cost of goods sold at 60% of…

Read more
Hand writing on paperwork with holographic market charts rising above, reflecting financial analysis, risk management, and results oriented planning.
Private Company Roadmap to Hedging FX, Interest Rate and Commodity Risks

Interest rate swaps, FX forwards, and commodity hedges are increasingly common among mid-market companies – yet the resources, systems, and technical expertise needed to maintain full ASC 815 compliance are often limited. For eligible private companies, ASC 815 Private Company Alternative offers a simplified hedge accounting approach for certain hedging instruments. In practice, private companies…

Read more
A business professional using an artificial intelligence interface, representing the innovation and impact of AI technology in reshaping industries and decision-making
When Quarterly Valuations Cannot Keep Pace: Managing AI Disruption Across the Private Equity Portfolio

Overview Recent pressure in private credit provides an important lesson for private equity managers: market signals can move materially faster than quarterly valuation processes. The issue may be particularly acute in software, where AI can alter competitive positioning, customer retention, pricing power and expected growth within a matter of months. Fund managers that establish a…