As more organizations embrace generative AI, one of the most common things we hear is: “Why doesn’t my Copilot Studio agent always follow the instructions I give it?” This reaction makes sense, especially if you’re used to rule-based chatbots, where writing a rule directly creates an agent behavior.
But generative AI doesn’t operate on strict rule-following. And that’s not a flaw, it’s actually one of its strengths. The key is to make sure that you approach agent design with realistic expectations.
Below is what every builder should know, written from the lens of how to set expectations that lead to success with Copilot Studio Agents.
Why Expectations are the Hidden Ingredient in Successful Agents
Copilot Studio agents use something called generative orchestration. Instead of relying on a fixed list of phrases and flows, the agent looks at the user’s message and chooses the most appropriate resource available: a tool, a knowledge article, a topic or even another agent.
This flexibility is powerful and creates more natural, human-like interactions.
But it also means your agent cannot follow instructions that depend on tools, data or knowledge it has not (yet) been given.
- If it doesn’t have access to a knowledge base, it can’t “check” that knowledge, no matter how clearly you instruct it.
- If no tool exists for a workflow step, the agent can’t perform that step just because you describe it.
In other words: clear instructions only work when paired with the right configuration.
This is not a limitation; it’s a design principle that supports governance, safety and quality. When teams understand this upfront, they can build agents that act predictably and responsibly.
What Instructions Can Influence Your Agents
When your agent has the right components configured, instructions become a powerful steering mechanism. They help determine:
- Which tool to call when there are multiple options
If several tools could work, instructions can guide the agent toward the best match for a given scenario. - How the final response is written
Instructions can shape:- tone,
- level of detail,
- formatting,
- ordering
- or use of bullets,tablesormarkdown.
- How the agent handles missing details
You can tell the agent when it should ask the user for clarification before taking an action that requires additional input. - What guardrails the agent should observe
Instructions can restrict the agent to a specific domain or task area. - How to handle multi-step workflows
Structured instructions help the agent understand the intended sequence of tasks and the specific tool interactions required.
These elements give builders a high degree of control as long as they pair instructions with well-designed tools and knowledge sources.
What Instructions Cannot Change About Agent Behavior
To set the right expectations, it’s equally important to know what instructions cannot influence.
Copilot Studio Agent instructions do not:
- change system fallback messages,
- rewrite default platform behaviors,
- ensure multilingual handling where the system does not already support it,
- bypass safety constraints
- or generate new abilities out of thin air.
If the system is missing a capability or a resource, no amount of instruction tuning will make the agent behave as if it exists.
This is why Withum emphasizes a configuration-first mindset— then instructions add refinement and polish.
How to Write Instructions That Copilot Agents Actually Follow
Here are the design principles that dramatically improve agent reliability:
- Align instructions with actual capabilities: Reference only the tools, data and knowledge sources the agent truly has. If you want the agent to use something, confirm it’s properly connected first.
- Be precise, specific and structured: Agents handle clear, direct language best. Use operational verbs (like “retrieve,” “summarize,” “search,” “compare”), and break multi-step logic into numbered lists or bullets.
- Add boundaries: Tell the agent which topics or tasks are in scope, and which ones are off-limits.
- Reference tool names exactly: When you want a particular workflow or process to run, use tool names consistently and explicitly.
- Expect the agent to ask for details when needed: If a tool requires user input and it’s not available, write instructions that guide how the agent should ask.
- Use instructions to shape, polish and increase professionalism: Formatting rules, tone definitions and response structures all help ensure consistency, especially important in enterprise environments.
- Test across real-world scenarios: Testing is where gaps show up, whether in missing tools, unclear instructions or unexpected edge cases. Every test helps refine the final design.
Withum’s Builder Checklist for Effective Copilot Studio Agent Instructions
Use this checklist to improve predictability and quality:
Capabilities Confirmed
- All referenced tools exist
- Knowledge sources are connected
- Tool and knowledge descriptions are clear and accurate
Instructions Are Clear and Operational
- Specific verbs used (retrieve, check, summarize, etc.)
- Steps broken down logically
- No vague phrasing
Scope and Boundaries Defined
- Clear description of allowed topics
- Explicit exclusions included
Clarification Logic Included
- Instructions specify when to ask the user for missing details
Response Presentation Defined
- Tone, formatting, structure and style described
Scenario Testing Completed
- Queries with missing information
- Ambiguous inputs
- Out-of-scope questions tested
- Key workflows confirmed
Exploring Copilot Studio or Other AI Agent Use Cases?
Find out if an Agent in a Day session would make sense for your organization. Get the practical skills needed to buildagentstailored to your business needs.
Key Takeaways
Great Copilot Studio agents aren’t just about writing clever instructions, they come from solid configuration and clear, realistic guidance. When builders understand what instructions can and can’t influence, design around actual capabilities and test with real scenarios, agent behavior becomes far more consistent, reliable and impactful. With the right expectations in place, teams can get the most out of generative AI and create experiences that feel both powerful and trustworthy.
AI Solutions That Deliver Results
Explore withum.ai, your resource for AI implementation and production-ready solutions. Find expert insights and practical guidance to move your business from ideas to impact.
Contact Us
Want your Copilot Studio agents to deliver real, consistent value? If you’re ready to see where AI can take you, reach out to our AI Services Team and let’s build something great together.
